Most pedigree practice problems are graded on the answer and taught as though the answer were the point. It is not. The answer is a genotype, and a genotype is easy once you know the inheritance pattern. The work is deciding the pattern, and that decision is made from the shape of the chart before a single letter goes on it.
Read a pedigree in this order, assuming the fully penetrant single-gene model these problems use. Two unaffected parents with an affected child means the trait is recessive: people who do not show it produced someone who does. Two affected parents with an unaffected child means it is dominant. Only then ask whether it is autosomal or X-linked.
Three charts below, solved in that order, with the reasoning written out at each step rather than saved for the answer key.
What do the symbols mean, and which parts are conventions?
Squares are males, circles are females, and a shaded symbol means the individual shows the trait. A horizontal line joins two individuals who have had children; a vertical line drops from that line to their offspring, drawn left to right in birth order. Generations are numbered with Roman numerals down the side, and individuals are numbered across each generation, so II-3 means the third person in the second generation.
All of that is convention. None of it carries biological meaning, so it is the part to memorize and stop thinking about. A pedigree, in the National Human Genome Research Institute’s glossary, is a chart that diagrams the inheritance of a trait or health condition through the generations of a family, and geneticists use it because the controlled crosses available with pea plants and fruit flies are not. OpenStax makes the same point when it introduces pedigree analysis: a test cross in humans is not an option, so the family tree is the data.
One thing to fix before you begin. The traits used in classroom pedigree exercises drawn from real human families are, as a rule, not clean single-gene traits. John H. McDonald’s survey at the University of Delaware is blunt about it: most of the common visible human traits used in classrooms do not have a simple one-locus, two-allele, dominant versus recessive inheritance. Tongue rolling is not dominant to non-rolling, and unattached earlobes are not dominant to attached. Some of these traits do not even fall into two distinct categories, since the underlying measurement is continuous.
So treat every pedigree in this post as what it is: an exercise in reasoning about a chart. The charts below use an unnamed trait on purpose. Published textbook examples use conditions with documented single-gene inheritance, which is why OpenStax uses one in its figure rather than something from a classroom survey. Another place where one ratio explains a pattern in biology is surface area to volume ratio, worked with real numbers.
Pedigree 1: two unaffected parents, one affected child
The chart. Generation I is a couple, I-1 (male, unaffected) and I-2 (female, unaffected). They have three children: II-1 (female, affected), II-2 (male, unaffected) and II-3 (female, unaffected). II-2 has children with II-4 (female, unaffected, married into the family), and those children are III-1 (male, unaffected) and III-2 (male, affected).
Step 1. Recessive or dominant? I-1 and I-2 both show nothing, and their daughter II-1 shows the trait. Under a dominant model an affected child must have at least one affected parent, because a single copy would show. Neither parent shows. So the trait is recessive, and II-1 carries two copies of an allele that neither parent displays. Call the alleles A for the common one and a for the trait.
Step 2. Autosomal or X-linked? This is where the affected daughter settles it. Under X-linked recessive inheritance, an affected female carries the allele on both of her X chromosomes, and one of those X chromosomes came from her father. A male has only one X, so a father who passed an affected X would himself show the trait. I-1 does not. X-linked recessive is therefore excluded, and the trait is autosomal recessive.
Step 3. Assign genotypes. II-1 is aa, since she shows a recessive trait. Both of her parents gave her an a, and neither shows the trait, so I-1 and I-2 are both Aa. III-2 is aa, which means each of his parents gave him an a, so II-2 is Aa and II-4 is Aa.
Step 4. What is left undetermined. II-3 is unaffected, so she is AA or Aa, and nothing in the chart distinguishes them. You can still say how likely each is. Her parents are Aa by Aa, which a Punnett square splits into one AA, two Aa and one aa. She is not aa, so she is one of the three remaining outcomes, two of which are Aa. Her chance of carrying the allele is 2 in 3. III-1 is in the same position relative to his own parents, so 2 in 3 for him as well.
That 1:2:1 is an expectation about large numbers of offspring from that cross, not a description of these three children. A family of three tells you almost nothing about ratios, which is exactly why pedigree reasoning proceeds by exclusion rather than by counting.
Pedigree 2: two affected parents, one unaffected child
The chart. Generation I is I-1 (male, affected) and I-2 (female, affected). Their children are II-1 (female, affected), II-2 (male, unaffected) and II-3 (male, affected). II-1 has children with II-4 (male, unaffected, married in): III-1 (female, affected), III-2 (male, unaffected) and III-3 (male, affected). II-3 has a child with II-5 (female, unaffected, married in): III-4 (male, affected).
Step 1. Recessive or dominant? Look at I-1, I-2 and II-2. If the trait were recessive, both affected parents would carry two copies of the trait allele and would have nothing else to pass, so every child would show it. II-2 does not. The trait is dominant. Call the dominant trait allele D and the other d.
Step 2. Autosomal or X-linked? Follow II-3 to III-4. II-3 is an affected male; his partner II-5 is unaffected. Under X-linked dominant inheritance, a father passes his X to his daughters and his Y to his sons, so an affected father cannot pass the trait to a son. The mother would have to supply it, and she does not have it. III-4 is an affected son. X-linked dominant is excluded, and the trait is autosomal dominant.
For a trait you have already established as dominant, this is the cleanest single observation available, and it is worth looking for first. It rules out X-linked dominant in one step. Note the scope: the argument works because a dominant allele on the father’s X would have to reach the son, and it cannot. It does not transfer to recessive traits, where a son’s X comes from his mother and his father’s phenotype is beside the point.
Step 3. Assign genotypes. II-2 shows nothing, so he is dd. He got a d from each parent, so I-1 and I-2 are both Dd. II-1 and II-3 are affected, so each is DD or Dd.
II-1 can be resolved. Her partner II-4 is unaffected, therefore dd, so every child receives a d from him. III-2 is unaffected, which means he is dd, so his other allele, from II-1, was also d. A DD mother has no d to give. II-1 is Dd.
II-3 cannot be resolved from what is drawn. His only child shown is affected, which is consistent with either DD or Dd. Saying so is the correct answer, not a failure to finish.
You can still put a number on it, and it is worth doing carefully because the obvious number is wrong. From his parents alone, Dd by Dd, and given that he is affected, he is one of three outcomes and two of them are Dd, so the chance would be 2 in 3. But the chart shows more than his parents. It shows that his one child is affected, and a DD father produces an affected child every time while a Dd father does so half the time, so the affected child is evidence pointing slightly toward DD. Updating on it: 2/3 x 1/2 gives 1/3 for the Dd route, 1/3 x 1 gives 1/3 for the DD route, and 1/3 out of a total of 2/3 is 1 in 2. Condition on the whole pedigree, not on the parents alone.
Step 4. Read it back in words. The trait appears in every generation, affected individuals each have an affected parent, and it shows up in both sexes. That is the signature of an autosomal dominant trait, and it is why the chart looked dominant before any of the algebra confirmed it. The link from a symbol on a chart to an allele you cannot see is the genotype and phenotype distinction doing all the work.
Pedigree 3: only males are affected
The chart. Generation I is I-1 (male, unaffected) and I-2 (female, unaffected). Their children are II-1 (male, affected), II-2 (female, unaffected) and II-3 (male, unaffected). II-2 has children with II-4 (male, unaffected, married in): III-1 (male, affected), III-2 (female, unaffected) and III-3 (male, unaffected).
Step 1. Recessive or dominant? I-1 and I-2 are both unaffected and II-1 is affected. Recessive, by the same argument as pedigree 1.
Step 2. Autosomal or X-linked? Now the sexes matter. Both affected individuals are male, and the affected grandson III-1 is connected to the affected uncle II-1 through an unaffected woman, II-2.
Test the two models by asking what each requires. Under autosomal recessive, III-1 is aa, so both II-2 and II-4 must carry the allele. II-4 married into the family, so the allele would have to enter this pedigree twice, from two unrelated sources.
Under X-linked recessive, a male has a single X, so one copy of the allele is enough to make him show the trait. III-1 needs only his mother II-2 to carry it, and her carrying it is explained by her own mother I-2, which also explains her brother II-1. One entry point instead of two.
X-linked recessive is the better-supported reading, and the pattern it predicts is the one drawn: affected individuals almost all male, unaffected mothers connecting them, and the trait appearing to skip generations. Be precise about the strength of the claim. Nothing in this chart makes autosomal recessive impossible. It makes it require a coincidence.
Step 3. Assign genotypes, writing X with a superscript as X-A for the common allele and X-a for the trait allele. II-1 is affected, so he is X-a Y. His mother I-2 gave him that X, and she is unaffected, so she is X-A X-a. His father I-1 is unaffected, so X-A Y. III-1 is affected, so X-a Y, and he got his X from his mother, so II-2 is X-A X-a. That is settled by the chart once you have committed to the X-linked reading, rather than being merely likely within it. II-3 and III-3 are unaffected males, so both are X-A Y, with no ambiguity at all, because a male has nothing to hide behind.
Step 4. What is left undetermined. III-2 is an unaffected female. Her father II-4 is unaffected and gave her X-A. Her mother II-2 is X-A X-a and gave her one of the two with equal chance. So III-2 is X-A X-A or X-A X-a, each with probability 1 in 2. That halving is the practical difference between the sexes here, and it comes straight from the fact that a female has two X chromosomes and a male has one, which is the same haploid and diploid bookkeeping applied to a single chromosome pair.
What would settle it. One observation would exclude X-linked recessive outright: an affected female whose father is unaffected, since her two affected X chromosomes would have to include one from him. Nothing like it appears here.
Be careful with the rule from pedigree 2, because it does not run in reverse. An affected father with an affected son excludes X-linkage only for a dominant trait. For a recessive one it proves nothing at all, because a son’s single X comes from his mother, so an affected father and a carrier mother produce affected sons without the father having transmitted anything. Knowing which observation would change your answer, and which one only looks like it would, is most of what pedigree analysis is.
The decision procedure, in four lines
Look for two unaffected parents with an affected child. Found it, the trait is recessive.
Look for two affected parents with an unaffected child. Found it, the trait is dominant.
For a dominant trait, look for an affected father with an affected son. Found it, autosomal.
For a recessive trait, count who is affected. Almost all male, with unaffected mothers linking them, points to X-linked; an affected female with an unaffected father rules X-linked out.
Then, and only then, start writing letters. Working the other way around, assigning genotypes first and hoping a pattern appears, is how an hour disappears into a chart with three generations.
When it is your own assigned pedigree rather than one of these, the useful thing is finding the individual where your reasoning and the correct reasoning diverge. Cyllo will take the chart as photographed and work it in this order, naming the exclusion at each step rather than returning a verdict, and stay in the conversation while you ask what would have changed if one symbol were shaded differently. Photo solving and AI chat run on a subscription; the topic quizzes, the flashcards and the biology reference do not.
One habit worth keeping
Write the exclusion, not just the conclusion. “Autosomal recessive” is a guess until it is followed by “because I-1 is an unaffected father with an affected daughter.” Questions on this material almost always ask for the justification, and the justification is a single sentence you already produced while solving it. The same discipline of stating which numbers are expectations and which are observations runs through the worked Hardy-Weinberg problems, and for the same reason: genetics goes wrong at the joints between a model and a measurement, not inside either one.
Sources
- 12.2 Characteristics and Traits, OpenStax Biology 2e
- 8.2 Laws of Inheritance, OpenStax Concepts of Biology
- Pedigree, Genetics Glossary, National Human Genome Research Institute
- X-Linked, Genetics Glossary, National Human Genome Research Institute
- John H. McDonald, Myths of Human Genetics: Introduction, University of Delaware